We went down to PA to visit Nate’s mom this past weekend and it was a fun, relaxing time as always. We stopped by a few antique shops on the search for some things I want to use in the wedding. I didn’t have much luck though. I’m thinking next time a flea market will be a better bet.

Another reason we went down is because Nate’s dad gave us a whole set of never-been-used bedroom furniture because he’s turning his guest room into a gym. Although we can’t fit the huge sleigh bed into our teeny NYC bedroom, we’re super excited about when we have room for it!

I figured after getting such a nice little present, I should say thank you in the only way I know how: baking.

After my success with making granola bars the other day, I thought about what else I could make from scratch that would be as good as or better than store-bought.

I had seen some look-alike Fig Newtons online and thought that I would have to try them. Nate told me his dad likes Fig Newtons so I thought it would be the perfect time to give this recipe a try. I wish I was closer to my parents, because growing up I remember my Dad loving Fig Newtons too. Next time I go down to Florida to visit, I’ll have to make these for him.

The dough was a but sticky and kind of ripped when I folder it over the filling, but all-in-all it was very forgiving after it cooked up. In addition, you definitely have to plan ahead with these since the dough has to be refrigerated for several hours and the filling takes a while to cook.

Next time I think I’ll try this with a different flavor inside :)

*Note, for great step-by-step pictures, visit the site I got the recipe from, Oh Nuts

Homemade Fig Newtons!

Taken from Oh Nuts

Print this recipe!

makes about 30 cookies

For the filling:

1 generous cup Calimyrna dried figs
1-1/2 cups water
1 cup apple juice
1/4 cup sugar
zest of 1/2 grated orange

For the cookie dough:
4 oz (8 tbsp) softened butter
1/2 cup granulated sugar
zest of 1/2 grated orange
1 egg white, room temperature
1 tsp vanilla extract
1.5 cups all-purpose flour

Both parts of this recipe require extensive down-time, so make sure you plan ahead and leave enough time for cooking and chilling. To make the dough, start by combining the butter and 1/2 cup of sugar in the bowl of stand mixer (or use a large bowl and a hand mixer.) Beat them together on medium speed until light and fluffy, about 2 minutes.

Add the egg white, the grated zest of half an orange, and the vanilla extract, and beat everything together until you have a silky smooth mixture. Scrape down the sides of the bowl and the beaters. Add the flour, and mix on low until everything is mixed together and there are no streaks of flour remaining.

When you’re finished, you should have a soft dough similar to a sugar cookie dough. Wrap it tightly in plastic wrap and refrigerate it until it’s firm enough to roll, for about two hours.

While you wait for the dough to chill, it’s time to get figgy with it! (Yes, I’ve been dying to use that joke this whole time.) Take those dried figs and chop them up into small pieces.

Combine the chopped figs, water, apple juice, and 1/4 cup of sugar in a medium saucepan, and bring it to a boil over medium heat. After it starts boiling, reduce the heat to low and simmer it until the figs are soft and practically disintegrating, anywhere from 90 minutes to 2 hours. Stir the figs occasionally so they don’t scorch on the bottom of the pan.

When the figs are done, most of the water will have cooked off and they will have the consistency of a thick, sticky jam. Cool the fig mixture at room temperature or in the microwave. It’s ok if it’s not as thick as you might think, as it will get blended.

Transfer the fig mixture to a food processor or blender, and add the grated zest of half an orange. Blend until you have a smooth paste.

Now it’s time to bring together the two halves of our Fig Newton. Preheat your oven to 350 degrees F.

Take your chilled dough from the refrigerator and dust a work surface and rolling pin with flour. The dough will get sticky as it warms up, so it’s best to do this quickly and avoid adding any more flour than necessary. Roll the dough out into a very thin rectangle, about 16 inches long by 12 inches high. Remember how thin the cookie part of a Fig Newton is? Yeah, it’s a wee little layer. That’s what we’re going for.

Cut your dough into 4 strips, so that you end up with 4 long thin rectangles 4 inches across and 12 inches high.

Take about a quarter of the fig mixture and spread it along the center of one of the strips of dough. Gently fold one side over the fig mixture, then fold the second side over the first, so that you are left with a long tube of dough enclosing the fig filling. Repeat until all four dough strips have been filled and folded.

Gently (gently!) transfer the strips of dough to a parchment-covered baking sheet. I found it was easiest to do this by sliding them onto a long metal spatula, but even a large chef’s knife might work for his purpose. You can either cut them into cookies before or after baking–I prefer before, because I think it’s a little easier to get clean cuts that way, but either way works fine.

Bake the cookies in the 350 degree oven for 12-15 minutes, until they’re puffed and golden brown around the edges.

**These cookies are even better the next day. Fresh from the oven, the cookie layer is a little crispy, more like a shortbread. But after they’ve had time to mellow, it softens like a real fig newton. Keep in tupperware on counter up to a week or longer in fridge.

21 Comments

  1. I love sending all sorts of messages through food and baked goods – thank you, i love you, you’re the best. They are all said best with some kind of confection. These look delicious!

  2. This is too cool. I used to enjoy fig newtons growing up and had never thought about making homemade versions. Now my mind is running. :-)

  3. Oh, lovely! I always kind of liked Fig Newtons growing up, but I never wanted to admit that I liked figs, or even that I actually knew what figs were, haha. Now that I am adult, I can actually admit that I do like them! Great job!

    • Thanks Jenni! I’m glad you’re able to admit to liking them now ;) Isn’t that funny that people are embarrassed to admit liking certain foods when they’re young? For some reason I was always embarrassed to bring a banana to school!

  4. I just love Fig Newtons, and this recipe looks really fun. I just got a can of poppyseed filling that I was planning on putting in some kind of pastry. They might be good as a filling here, maybe? I’ve never cooked with poppyseed filling before so I’m not sure what kind of consistency it’s going to have.

    In any event, I love this post!

    • Poppyseed filling would be totally awesome! It’s actually traditionally used in this Jewish pastry that’s kinda like a big danish. I’m not sure what it’s called but it’s sooo good. But I think it would work equally well in these. Def lemme know if you give it a try :)

  5. Nicole@HeatOvenTo350

    Wow, these ended up looking so perfect! I’m really impressed. I think food “Thank You”s are some of the best ‘Thank You’s of all.

  6. Hmmm… let’s try that again ;-)

    NO WAY!! I was just chatting with Charles over at FiveEuroFood about homemade Fig Newtons and how cool it would be to attempt to make them… you rock Amy! Love the grated orange and the idea of changing up the flavourings inside… These look fantastic and what great inspiration.

    • What a weird coincidence. You and I are always on the same wavelength, Kelly! They really weren’t all that difficult and were extremely forgiving. You should give them a try :) I think I’ll make them again soon with a diff filling.

  7. Amy – the pastries are hamentashen, a traditional tri-cornered cookie eaten during the Jewish holiday of Purim.

  8. wow i am so impressed! i grew up eating fig newtons! you always amaze me with your baked creations :D

  9. Homemade is always so much better. I can’t even imagine how delicious these must have tasted. I’m sure even better than they look–if that’s possible! x

    • Thanks, Caroline :) They weren’t a perfect match for fig newtons, but I think it’s because they were so much fresher and more delicious!

  10. I’m sure your homemade “thank you” was really appreciated. They look great.

Leave a Reply